Copenhagen Memo — taragraphies

Copenhagen
Memo

Series Longform
Location Copenhagen, Denmark
Dates Dec 10–18, 2009
Event UNFCCC COP15
Read

Countdown Clock

The moment I touched down at Copenhagen's Kastrup Airport, my heart raced with anticipation. I immediately pulled up the UN Climate Summit website, and there it was — the Countdown to Copenhagen clock, ticking relentlessly. Exactly 24 hours remained until humanity's most pivotal meeting would begin. The weight of history pressed down on me as I stared at the numbers, each second a reminder of how little time was left to act.

Stepping out of the airport, I was greeted by striking billboards that stopped me in my tracks. Stark images of aging world leaders stared back, their haunting message loud and clear: "I'm sorry. We could have prevented catastrophic climate change… we didn't." It was impossible to look away. The urgency in the air was electrifying, and the stakes had never felt higher.

Greenpeace billboard campaign
Courtesy of Greenpeace · Hopenhagen billboard campaign

All advertisements featured Lula of Brazil, Tusk of Poland, Brown of the United Kingdom, Merkel of Germany, Sarkozy of France, Zapatero of Spain, Medvedev of Russia, Harper of Canada, and Rudd of Australia — part of Greenpeace's campaign to remind them of their responsibility to future generations. The demand: a

FairAmbitiousBinding
deal for the climate and for all life on the planet.

Thousands of people descended on Copenhagen for this one-of-a-kind summit — COP15, the 15th Conference of Parties. All hotels, hostels, and accommodations had been transformed into makeshift housing for the thousands expected in the coming days. I found a bed at a youth hostel, sharing a small room with six young Friends of the Earth members from Germany.

On the first day, a kilometre-long queue of participants waited in freezing weather for registration. Negotiating teams, journalists from 192 countries, and a mass of NGOs and civil societies — all shivering, all urgent. The Greenpeace Café pushed hot coffee and the FAB deal. A large screen showed video clips from the climate defender camp in Sumatra's Kampar peninsula, climate impact in the Pacific.

Coming from Bangkok for my first climate summit, I was unable to register on the first day — my name was still waiting to be added to the GCCA list. But I was transfixed by the view of the entire Bella Center compound from the metro elevated platform: a large wind turbine behind, a power plant pumping a smoke plume on the horizon. I hoped for the best. Otherwise, the Copenhagen summit would be nothing more than a showcase of corporate-driven climate solutions and a never-ending political debate.

The UNFCCC website's countdown clock read zero. The talks begin under Copenhagen's gloomy sky.

Keep Talking…
The Boat Is Ready

Boat listing all COPs
A boat listing every Climate COP since 1992. Photo: Tara Buakamsri

Unfortunately I missed the highlight of the first day — when Leah Wickham, a young woman from Fiji, spoke on behalf of more than 10 million people who signed the tcktcktck petition. And Abigail Jabines, International Solar Generation Coordinator, presented Yvo De Boer, UNFCCC Executive Secretary, with Denmark's famous Lego: a building block for a fair, ambitious, and binding agreement.

Wickham's concluding words echoed throughout Copenhagen: "The time for talking is over, and now it's time for action."

De Boer's retort, somewhere between diplomacy and comedy: "…but I hope you will be a bit patient and give us two more weeks of talking and then we will deliver on the action…"

There was a lot to decide in two weeks — GHG reduction targets for the second Kyoto commitment period, whether Carbon Capture and Storage would enter the CDM, whether REDD would slow tropical deforestation. But in the end, we needed leaders who act, not politicians who talk.

Every Conference of Parties — 1992 to 2009
Earth SummitRio de Janeiro, Brazil, 1992
COP 1Berlin, Germany, 1995
COP 2Geneva, Switzerland, 1996
COP 3Kyoto, Japan, 1997
COP 4Buenos Aires, Argentina, 1998
COP 5Bonn, Germany, 1999
COP 6The Hague, Netherlands, 2000
COP 6+Bonn, Germany, 2001
COP 7Marrakech, Morocco, 2001
COP 8New Delhi, India, 2002
COP 9Milan, Italy, 2003
COP 10Buenos Aires, Argentina, 2004
COP 11Montreal, Canada, 2005
COP 12Nairobi, Kenya, 2006
COP 13Bali, Indonesia, 2007
COP 14Poznan, Poland, 2008
COP 15Copenhagen, Denmark, 2009 ←

On my way back from Bella Center, I encountered young people handing out leaflets for Klima Forum 09 — the civil society counterpart to COP15. De Boer had his two weeks and no more. A photo of a boat listing every single Climate Conference of Parties since 1992 said it all. Enough is enough; the time for climate action is clearly now.

The Entrance

"I was at war in Vietnam," said the charismatic elderly gentleman of American-Indian origin sitting next to me on the bus to Bella Centre. A member of indigenous peoples networks at COP15, he was heading to a TV interview at Klima Forum when we started talking. "After a year of war, during my transition period in Hawaii, I reflected and decided to change the way I live my life. I decolonized myself. Now I'd like to join the global call for climate justice."

I sometimes felt lost in the massive crowd of over 25,000 people in Copenhagen, but it was easy to meet like-minded people from every corner of the world, sharing a common vision.

Today I was following the instructions: "…After passing through the registration area and the ID badge checkpoint, proceed straight ahead past the cloakroom and through the exhibition area to a set of double doors with a banner advertising the NGO Climate Rescue Station above them…"

Climate Rescue Station
The NGO Climate Rescue Station inside Bella Center. Photo: Tara Buakamsri

The Climate Rescue Station had history. In Poland 2008, it stood on the edge of Europe's biggest open-cast coal mine. At COP14, it moved to Poznan town square, hosting the British Symphonia Orchestra. At Glastonbury 2009, it was an information center against Heathrow's third runway. Now, here in Copenhagen, it hosted "Consequences" — a photo exhibition of climate impacts the world was already experiencing.

Kumi Naidoo, Greenpeace International's new Executive Director, was present and delivered an inspiring message in response to the powerful photographs.

I introduced Thai negotiators and NGO colleagues to the station: "Well, it's a smoking area and you can get free coffee, so please come and relax from the very tense and chaotic atmosphere inside." Push through the doors, past many smokers, turn left — and there it was, the climate rescue station that could, at the very least, save me from the talking circus in the big hall.

Samba Drums

Global Day of Climate Action rally
Global Day of Climate Action, Copenhagen. Photo: Tara Buakamsri

Two police and military helicopters hovered in the clear blue sky over Christiansborg Slotsplads — Parliament Square — where over 100,000 people had gathered to mark the Global Day of Climate Action, taking place simultaneously in more than 130 countries.

Even at noon, the temperature was 2°C. I joined 200 Greenpeace volunteers in light green jackets bearing the words "Act Now, Change the Future." A giant floating snowman, a floating globe in a lifebuoy — and leading it all, the Samba Drum team, the day's coolest volunteers.

"Let's stick with them so we don't get lost," I told Topsi, a former Greenpeace action coordinator from Thailand now studying in Germany, who'd come here to represent the University of Freiburg at COP15.

In more than 20 years of activism, this was the largest climate demonstration I had ever attended. Over 500 organisations from environmental, development, faith, labour, youth, and political sectors — Greenpeace, Oxfam, 350.org, Avaaz, IndyAct, ActionAid, WWF, Climate Justice Action, and many more.

From the bridge I continued walking, dancing, holding a "Climate Justice NOW" placard with the Samba Drums gang to Christiania, then through Tingvij/Frankrigsgade. By the time we reached the Bella Center area, the sky was dark. Outside the venue, a stage cut across the road.

"It is wonderful to see a human sea of light bringing a message of hope and solidarity — most of the people in the room stopped talking and came out to see it on the screen."

— Wanun Permpiboon, Thai activist inside the Bella Center

The on-stage speakers eventually made their way to the Bella Center to hand ship sails to UNFCCC Executive Secretary Yvo De Boer. All Greenpeace volunteers boarded buses bound for the warehouse for a debrief. Topsi messaged later: "Samba Drums begin playing now for volunteer party." I'd already left. I missed the best part.

In the Arctic Sunrise, anchored in Copenhagen harbour since the summit's start, a banner on the deck read: "Politicians Talk, Leaders Act."

Bella Center

COP15 plenary
COP15 plenary session. Photo: Tara Buakamsri

Late Sunday morning, colleagues asked me to assist in transporting Thai community leaders to Climate Justice Now's "Hit the Production" action targeting the harbour. The plan was soon abandoned — too dangerous, arrests of Thai community members possible, and none of them were equipped for extreme cold. They would instead meet Thailand's Environment Minister, Khun Suvit Khunkitti.

We walked to the Marriott Hotel — seven community leaders from the Northern, Eastern, North-eastern, Central, and Southern parts of Thailand, plus five Thai activists — and met the Minister in the lobby. The core question: the Thai government's position in the negotiations.

Thailand stood for legally binding commitments for developed countries, and "Nationally Appropriate Mitigation Actions" for developing countries on a voluntary basis, with financing, technology transfer, and capacity building from the developed world. Thailand clearly wanted to keep the spirit of Kyoto alive. But negotiations were moving slowly, with controversies about CDM funds for nuclear power and CCS.

"Isn't it true that all multilateral environmental agreement negotiations should be for the benefit of the entire country and its people, not for corporate greed?"

The second week brought terrible news: a large number of NGOs and civil society members would be denied access to the Bella Center. The African group was withdrawing. Tuvalu had suspended negotiations, insisting on full debate of proposals to amend both the UN Climate Convention and the Kyoto Protocol.

"It has become clear that the Danish presidency is advancing developed-country interests at the expense of the balance of obligations between developed and developing countries."

I passed Environment Minister Suvit in the corridor — he was also walking out, supporting the African group's position. This was my last chance to track the Thai negotiating team from within. I wasn't getting the second badge. Yuyun from Greenpeace Southeast Asia summed it up: "I am more than happy not to get the second badge. I want to get out of here!!!"

Flopenhagen

Giant model earth at tcktcktck
Photo: Tara Buakamsri

After the UNFCCC restricted NGOs from the Bella Center, "Hopenhagen" became "Flopenhagen." My roommates — one from Kenya, another from Kiribati — lay frustrated on their beds, unable to enter. I ran between Klima Forum and the NGO gathering places, catching up with colleagues from around the world.

The big Copenhagen treaty — meant to replace the Kyoto Protocol — was already in jeopardy. Danish Prime Minister Rasmussen had effectively ruled it out even before the conference began. Even Al Gore was speaking of a watered-down deal. Not what the world wants and needs.

"We want Copenhagen to not be remembered as a 'Flopenhagen.' We want a Hopenhagen."

— Kumi Naidoo, Greenpeace International Executive Director

Everywhere in the city — on the bus, train, metro, billboard, newspaper — I saw advertisements for "Hopenhagen." Cultural events around the city: exhibitions, architecture, art, film, music. But at one bus stop, Coca-Cola sponsored, someone had written the letter "S" in front and it read "Shopenhagen." Another, sponsored by Siemens, had a short sentence added in marker: "Our climate, not your business!"

On a late bus from Bella Center, a bus driver complained about the troublemakers from around the world. Wanun Permpiboon, who'd been assisting the Thai negotiating team on adaptation text with G77 parties, wrote: "So I look at myself, oh well, I am one of them."

My Thai colleague Topsi and I were delighted to meet Sven Teske, the legendary leader of Greenpeace's Energy Revolution, on board the Arctic Sunrise. Spicy Thai noodles and cheap beer in the Copenhagen winter. "I want to remove the bracket from 'E' in our next energy revolution report," Sven said. His next mission: a 350ppm scenario, a 1.5-degree limit. "Then that's all I need."

Crackdown

Police crackdown outside Bella Center
Police crackdown near Bella Center. Photo: Tara Buakamsri

Climate Justice Action activists planned to enter COP15 and stage a People's Assembly. The Bella Center Metro station had been closed. Barricades and a defensive wall were erected. Thai community members woke very early to join the rally in Sundby. Khun Srisuwan and I took the S train from Central Station.

By Thursday, access was down to no more than 1,000 civil society representatives permitted inside the Bella Center. On the final day: only 90.

At noon, I ran into Emmy Hafild, former Executive Director of Greenpeace Southeast Asia, hurrying out. She used two words to describe what was happening inside: "Chaos" and "disaster."

"Front-line demonstrators are then pepper-sprayed and beaten with batons. Some attempted to cross a canal surrounding the venue by scaling fences, climbing over police vans, and even using flotation devices."

— Penchom Tang, Thai Working Group for Climate Justice

I was stopped by police as I tried to follow delegates marching out of Bella Center to join the demonstration. Approximately 230 people were arrested that day. A group of 50 NGOs wrote an open letter to Yvo de Boer:

"It is intolerable that civil society observers be restricted in this forum… The UNFCCC/Kyoto Protocol negotiations have a huge and growing impact on the lives of ordinary people all over the world. Their participation is critical to ensuring that the Copenhagen outcomes are both just and effective."

"Thai activists are safe," Khun Srisuwan confirmed after learning they had returned to their temporary residence, a stadium outside Copenhagen.

Red Carpet,
Speeches & Debate

Heads of state at COP15
World leaders arrive for COP15

Since Wednesday night it had been snowing. The entire Copenhagen landscape had turned white. With journalist Khun Amarit from Thailand's Public Broadcasting Service, I boarded bus 250S to Gladsaxe Stadium, just outside the city centre, as the heads of state arrived for the Queen's Gala Dinner at Christiansborg Slot.

A Greenpeace convoy with a fictitious head of state had made it to the red carpet. Banners proclaimed: "Politicians Talk, Leaders Act." The Queen of Denmark delivered her address: "it is our hope that as you leave Copenhagen, you have achieved positive and convincing results."

On Danish television, a remarkable live debate: Kevin Rudd, Buyelwa Sonjica, Mohamed Nasheed of the Maldives, and Felipe Calderón of Mexico. Kumi Naidoo in the audience arguing for a fair, ambitious, binding deal. And Lumumba Stanislaus Di-Aiping, Chief Negotiator of the G77, citing Archbishop Desmond Tutu: "Better no deal than bad deal."

Nasheed immediately cut in: "We are in the G77 and we do not agree with that viewpoint at all. We must reach an agreement."

Calderón concluded simply: "This is the only world we have, and we don't have much time left."

"Industrialised countries have brought climate talks to the brink of collapse by refusing to accept deeper greenhouse gas emissions cuts or provide adequate funding for developing country action and adaptation."

— Greenpeace International Political Team communiqué

Leadership Crisis

Bend the Trend billboard
"Bend the Trend" — European Environmental Agency billboard, Copenhagen

Friday late evening was bitterly cold. After leaving Oksnehallen Hall — the alternative venue provided by the Danish Foreign Minister after the Bella Center restricted access — I walked the long stretch from City Hall Square to the outdoor photo exhibition: "100 places to remember before they disappear."

Set against a large billboard on the European Environmental Agency's building that read "Bend the Trend!" — a graph depicting GHG emissions and global temperatures from 1970 to 2050. Two arrows: one upward ("Doing Nothing More"), one downward ("Acting Ambitiously Together").

And there it was, among the 100 doomed places: Bangkok. Where I live. "The Sinking City of Angels." The photo was actually of Samut Sakhon or Samut Songkram — provinces near Bangkok — but the caption was for all of us:

"Located in one of Asia's mega deltas and only two meters above sea level, Bangkok is massively exposed to flooding… Some estimates suggest that the whole city is subsiding by as much as 5 cm a year… Unless urgent steps are taken, large parts of Bangkok could be under water before the end of the century."

The temperature kept dropping. I was becoming increasingly cold — in more than one sense.

"…The Copenhagen Climate Summit has been on the calendar for two years. That the leaders of the rich world have turned up here with empty rhetoric and even emptier pockets beggars belief… It is not FAIR… It is not AMBITIOUS… It is not LEGALLY BINDING… Time is almost up. Will this day be remembered as the day the rich world took a giant step towards averting climate chaos, or will it go down in history as the day the death warrants of millions were signed…"

— Greenpeace International Political Team

I recalled what the Maldives' President Mohamed Nasheed had said: "You cannot bargain with mother nature."

Even if no FAB climate deal emerged from Copenhagen, the climate movement of ordinary people would continue and grow. I was not going down without a fight.


"When we are on the verge of environmental destruction or in the midst of a climate crisis, we as humans have the ability to transform the crisis into an opportunity."

— Tara Buakamsri, Copenhagen, December 2009

taragraphies · Longform Series · Bangkok, Thailand
We use cookies to personalise content and ads, to provide social media features and to analyse our traffic. We also share information about your use of our site with our social media, advertising and analytics partners. View more
Cookies settings
Accept
Privacy & Cookie policy
Privacy & Cookies policy
Cookie name Active
  Military VS Climate Security : The 2011 Budget Compareสถาบันนโยบายศึกษาในสหรัฐอเมริกา จัดทำรายงานประจำปีเรื่อง Military VS Climate Security : The 2011 Budget Compare" ออกมาเมื่อเร็วๆ นี้ เนื้่อหาในรายงานระบุว่า ตอนนี้กลาโหมของสหรัฐฯ รู้แล้วว่า การเปลี่ยนแปลงสภาพภูมิอากาศ(climate change) ถือเป็น "ตัวคูณของภัยคุกคามด้านความมั่นคง" หลักฐานประการหนึ่งคือ นับตั้งแต่ปี 2008 เป็นต้นมา งบประมาณของรัฐบาลสหรัฐฯ เองได้ถูกแบ่งสรรปันส่วนไปใช้ในเรื่องการจัดการกับเรื่องการเปลี่ยนแปลงสภาพภูมิอากาศมากขึ้น ตั้งแต่ปี 2008 และปี 2011 มีการจัดสรรงบโลกร้อนเพิ่มขึ้นเป็นมากกว่าสองเท่า (จาก 7.4 พันล้านเหรียญ เป็น 18.1 พันล้านเหรียญ) กล่าวอีกนัยหนึ่ง ในปี 2008 สหรัฐฯ นั้นใช้งบประมาณราว 94 เหรียญสหรัฐในด้านกลาโหม ต่อทุก ๆ 1 เหรียญสหรัฐที่ใช้ในด้านการจัดการเรื่องการเปลี่ยนแปลงสภาพภูมิอากาศ และในปี 2011 ใช้งบระมาณราว 41 เหรียญสหรัฐในด้านกลาโหม ต่อทุกๆ 1 เหรียญสหรัฐที่ใช้ในด้านการจัดการเรื่องการเปลี่ยนแปลงสภาพภูมิอากาศ แต่สิ่งที่น่าสนใจก็คือ การเปลี่ยนผ่านของการใช้งบประมาณดังกล่าวนี้ มิได้ทำให้การลงทุนเพื่อทำให้เกิดความมั่นคงด้านสภาพภูมิอากาศมากนักเมื่อเทียบกับขนาดของภัยคุกคามของการเปี่ลยนแปลงสภาพภูมิอากาศที่เกิดขึ้นและรออยู่ข้างหน้า ยิ่งไปกว่านั้น รายงานนี้ยังได้เปรียบเทียบกรณีศึกษาประเทศจีนว่ามีความก้าวหน้ามากกว่าสหรัฐอเมริกาในเรื่องนี้มาก รายงานระบุว่า ถึงแม้การใช้จ่ายทางการทหารของจีนจะไม่โปร่งใสไปเสียทั้งหมด แต่จีนนั้นใช้งบประมาณ 2-3 เหรียญสหรัฐในด้านกลาโหม ต่อทุก ๆ 1 เหรียญสหรัฐที่ใช้ในด้านการจัดการเรื่องการเปลี่ยนแปลงสภาพภูมิอากาศ รายงานนี้ ได้สรุปฟันธงว่า ไม่ว่าจะเป็นเหตุผลทั้งในด้านความมั่นคง ทางสิ่งแวดล้อม และทางเศรษฐกิจ การจัดสรรงบประมาณและทรัพยากรในด้านกลาโหมให้กับงบประมาณในการจัดการด้านการเปลี่ยนแปลงสภาพภูมิอากาศมากขึ้น เป็นเรื่องที่สมเหตุสมผลสำหรับสหรัฐอเมริกา รายละเอียดของรายงานดาวน์โหลดได้ที่  www.fpif.org/files/2521/mil%20v%20climate%202010.pdf
Save settings
Cookies settings